After a burglary or a burst pipe, many collectors discover two questions they never asked: is the collection actually insured — and how do I prove what it was worth?
The second is usually the harder one. We will go through both. This is not legal or insurance advice: policy terms vary by country and by insurer, and your own policy is what counts.
Home contents insurance
A card collection is part of your household contents and is, in principle, covered by home contents insurance against the usual perils such as fire, water damage, storm and burglary.
Three points decide whether that is enough when it matters.
1. Valuables limits
Many policies class collections as valuables — stamps and coins are often named explicitly. Valuables usually have their own payout limit, frequently a percentage of the total sum insured, and often a lower limit if they were not kept in a safe.
Whether trading cards fall under this is in your policy terms — and if it is not spelled out, a short written question to your insurer is worth it.
2. Underinsurance
The sum insured should reflect the value of all your contents, collection included. If it is too low, the insurer may reduce even a partial claim. A collection that has risen in value over the years can quietly make a sum that used to be right too low.
3. What is typically not covered
- Theft without forced entry — at a trade event, for example.
- Cards away from home are often only covered in a limited way, up to a cap.
- Cards in the post, for grading or a sale. The carrier’s liability applies there.
- Gradual damage such as damp or fading.
When specialist cover makes sense
If the collection is worth well above the valuables limits, there are two routes: extend the contents policy (higher limits for a higher premium) or take out dedicated collectibles insurance. The latter insures individual items or the whole collection at an agreed value and can also cover theft away from home, transit and exhibitions.
Which is cheaper depends on the value — getting a quote for both costs nothing.
Proof is what decides it
An insurer pays what you can document. “There was a Charizard in there and it was worth a lot” is not enough. What helps:
- An inventory listing card, set, card number, language, variant, condition and current market value. Not just the expensive cards — the mid-range ones often add up to a large share.
- Photos of the front and back of valuable cards, plus overview shots of binders and boxes where they are kept.
- Receipts, order confirmations and bank statements.
- For slabs, the certification numbers — they document card and grade independently of you.
- Update it regularly, at least once a year and after larger purchases.
Keep a copy outside your home, for example in cloud storage. An inventory that burns along with the collection does not help.
A CardBroker portfolio is essentially that inventory: every card is recorded with set, variant and condition and has a current market value with its history. How the values are worked out is explained under data sources.
Avoiding damage
The best insurance is the one that never has to pay out:
- Not on the floor, not against an outside wall — that is where water and damp arrive first.
- No direct sunlight. It fades colours, even behind glass.
- A stable room climate. Big swings cause warping, especially on holo cards.
- Keep valuable cards separate and out of sight, not on an open shelf.
- Do not advertise what is kept where — including on social media with your home recognisable in the background.
How condition affects a card’s value is covered in the guide to card condition.
An inventory that keeps itself up to date
A CardBroker portfolio records every card with set, variant and condition and keeps its market value current — the basis for any proof of value. The free plan covers 50 cards.
Get it free