Fakes are no longer just the obvious bargain-bin cards full of typos. Good fakes look real at first glance — and they show up precisely on the sought-after cards where money is involved.
The good news: hardly any fake passes all of the checks below. So the most important rule comes first: always compare against a card you know is genuine, ideally from the same era.
1. The price
The first check happens before you buy. A card offered well below its market value almost always has a reason. A seller offering lots of “rare” cards cheaply at once, even more so.
2. The light test
Genuine Pokémon cards are made of several layers of paper with a dark layer in between. Hold the card in front of a phone torch: on a real card only muted light comes through. Many fakes let noticeably more light through, or glow evenly bright.
The test is strong evidence, not proof — cards from different eras differ. So here too: compare against a genuine card.
3. The colours
Put the card next to a real one. Fakes are often too washed out or too saturated. The back is especially revealing: the blue on genuine cards has a characteristic swirl of lighter and darker areas. On fakes it is frequently too light, too purple or too flat.
4. Font and symbols
Look closely at the text, ideally with your camera zoom:
- Is the typeface the same as on genuine cards, or does it look heavier, thinner or slightly off?
- Do spacing, line breaks and the position of the HP match?
- Are the energy symbols the right shape and centred?
- Are there spelling mistakes, wrong attack names or nonsensical numbers? Then you already have your answer.
5. The holo pattern
Tilt holo cards slowly under a light. Genuine holos have a pattern typical of their era, with depth to it. Fakes often show a flat rainbow sheen over the whole card, the wrong pattern, or foil where the real card has none. Where the foil belongs on each variant is covered in the guide to holo and reverse holo.
6. The surface
Modern full-art cards and many secret rares have a texture you can feel — fine ridges that follow the artwork. Fakes are usually smooth there. Conversely, some fakes of regular cards are glossier than the original.
7. The edge
Look at the cut edge with a loupe or your camera zoom. On many genuine cards the dark middle layer shows as a thin line. Fakes often lack it, or the edge looks unevenly cut.
The popular rip test is not recommended: it works, but it destroys the card. It is only useful for a card that is worthless anyway.
8. Weight and thickness
A jeweller’s scale (0.01 g) lets you compare cards. Fakes often differ measurably because they use different stock. Only compare against a genuine card of the same era and type — holo and textured cards weigh differently from regular ones.
Fake slabs
With graded cards, it is not just the card that gets faked but the case too. Two checks are essential:
- Look up the certification number. PSA, Beckett and CGC all offer a lookup for the number on the label on their websites. Do the card, set and grade match the record? For many PSA records there is a photo as well.
- Inspect the case. Compare label font, hologram and build quality against a genuine slab from the same company. Scratches or marks along the seam can indicate a case that was opened and resealed.
A real certification number alone proves nothing: counterfeiters like to copy numbers from existing cards. Always compare the card itself against the record.
If you are unsure
- When buying on a platform: use buyer protection and never pay outside the platform.
- Before buying, ask for photos of front and back in normal light, not just polished product shots.
- If in doubt, submit the card for grading — fakes do not receive a grade. Whether that is worth it is what the grading calculator works out.
The TCG card scanner identifies which card a photo shows and puts the catalogue image next to it for comparison. That is not an authenticity check — for that you need the card in your hand.
Know which card you are holding
The scanner identifies set, card number and variant from a photo — the starting point for checking a card against the original and knowing its value. The free plan covers 50 cards.
Get it free